For the Islanders, Rostyn Griffiths and Jorge Pereyra Diaz scored, but Jerry Mawia and Roy Krishna scored for the Juggernauts.
The Indian Super League match between former champions Mumbai City FC and Odisha FC ended in a thrilling 2-2 tie on Thursday.
At the beginning of the first half, Jerry Mawia took advantage of a defensive blunder by Akash Mishra to give Odisha the lead.
However, two minutes into the second half, Mumbai scored an equaliser.
Greg Stewart delivered the ideal cross, and Rostyn Griffiths leapt above the Odisha defenders to head it in.
Krishna was struck hard by Mumbai's Nawaz, and the referee gave Krishna a penalty, which he easily converted.
Mumbai, though, evened the score in the 89th minute.
Jorge Diaz headed a beautiful cross from Vikram Pratap Singh into the goal to give both teams a draw.